Business Leaders: Essential to Safeguard Democracy and Stability
America's democratic decline into 'incracy' poses significant economic risks. Business leaders are crucial for restoring stability and ensuring long-term prosperity.
Key Insights
-
Insight
Partial democracies, or "incracies," are the most unstable governmental forms, exhibiting higher rates of political, economic, and social instability compared to full democracies or hardline autocracies.
Impact
Businesses operating in or exposed to 'incracy' environments face unpredictable policy changes, market volatility, and increased operational risks, directly impacting profitability and long-term viability.
-
Insight
By December 2020, the U.S. had entered the "incracy" zone according to the CIA's own political instability model, alongside a rise in identity-based political organization.
Impact
This classification suggests heightened and accelerating risk for the U.S. business environment, potentially leading to reduced investment, hindered innovation, and greater economic uncertainty for domestic and international firms.
-
Insight
Incracies suffer lower GDP per capita, reduced economic growth rates, and decreased investment, directly undermining the conditions necessary for business prosperity and innovation.
Impact
Companies in unstable partial democracies will experience diminished market opportunities, capital scarcity, and a challenging environment for expansion and innovation, affecting all business sizes.
-
Insight
The business community is arguably the most powerful actor in American politics, with significant influence over elections and policy decisions.
Impact
This leverage presents a critical opportunity for business leaders to proactively influence political outcomes towards stability, thereby protecting their own long-term interests and the broader economic landscape.
-
Insight
Even large businesses, despite potential initial benefits, are ultimately severely harmed in autocratic systems through aggressive state actions like regulations, lawsuits, asset seizure, and forced bankruptcies, as seen in Hungary.
Impact
Business leaders must understand that short-term alliances with aspiring autocrats carry extreme long-term risks, potentially leading to total loss of assets and market control, contradicting fiduciary duties to shareholders.
-
Insight
Once a country falls into incracy, only approximately 20% successfully return to full democracy, usually within a tight window of five to eight years.
Impact
This narrow window emphasizes the urgency for business intervention; delays in addressing democratic decline drastically reduce the chances of a stable environment for future economic activity and investment.
Key Quotes
"The most unstable place to be as a government is in this middle zone. Political instability and political violence is extremely rare in strong healthy democracies. It's actually relatively rare in hardcore autocracies. Almost all the violence and the significant instability, and that's political, economic, and social instability, happens in this middle zone."
"Business is probably the most powerful actor in American politics simply because of the way our political system is structured. They have an enormous influence in who gets elected, what policies they pursue, and so if business were willing to get involved, it could have a big influence."
"They could either have apartheid or they could have profits, but they could not have both."
Summary
The Perilous Middle Ground: Why Business Must Champion Democracy Now
America, long seen as the bastion of democracy, has quietly slipped into a dangerous "middle zone" of political instability. This isn't just a political science theory; it's a data-driven reality with profound implications for the business world, from the smallest startup to the largest multinational corporation. The health of our economy is inextricably linked to the stability of our political system, and leading experts are sounding the alarm: business leaders are uniquely positioned to act as democracy's last, best hope.
Understanding the 'Incracy' Threat
Research from the former CIA Political Instability Task Force identified "incracy"—a partial democracy exhibiting elements of both democracy and autocracy—as the most volatile governmental state. Unlike stable democracies or even hardcore autocracies, incracies are hotbeds of political, economic, and social instability. Disturbingly, by December 2020, the U.S. had entered this precarious zone, coupled with an alarming rise in identity-based political organization—a key predictor of escalating risk.
Economically, the data is stark: incracies suffer lower GDP per capita, reduced growth rates, and diminished investment. This environment chokes innovation, stifles new companies, and creates a volatile landscape where long-term planning becomes a gamble.
Business: The Most Powerful Pillar
While political leaders and voters often struggle with gridlock or collective action problems, the business community emerges as a critical, often underutilized, pillar of power. With enormous influence over elections and policy, corporations and their leaders can shape the political narrative and steer the nation away from instability.
History provides powerful lessons. In Brazil, major business leaders united in a public service campaign before the 2022 election, advocating for democracy without condemning specific candidates. This collective action contributed to record turnout and the defeat of an aspiring autocrat. Similarly, in apartheid-era South Africa, economic sanctions forced white business leaders to choose between "apartheid or profits," ultimately leading them to back the transition to a black majority government.
The Long Game: Why Autocracy Fails Business
Some might believe that large corporations can thrive, or at least survive, under an authoritarian regime. The data tells a different story. While initial alliances might offer a temporary "bump" to big industries, autocrats eventually seek to consolidate all power, often at the expense of even their former allies. Hungary's trajectory illustrates this starkly: 15 years into its autocratic shift, many wealthy Hungarian companies faced aggressive state actions—regulations, lawsuits, and forced bankruptcies—only to see their assets acquired by government loyalists for pennies on the dollar. Small businesses and startups are hit immediately, with innovation "falling off a cliff."
The Window for a U-Turn is Narrow
Once a country descends into incracy, reversing course is exceptionally difficult. Only about 20% of countries manage to make a "U-turn" back to full democracy, and this typically happens within a tight window of five to eight years. The longer a nation lingers in this unstable middle zone, the harder it becomes to escape.
A Call to Action for Leaders
The message to business and technology leaders is clear: take the threat seriously, now. Procrastination is not an option.
1. Coordinate and Collaborate: Break the collective action problem by forming alliances and working together to champion democratic principles. 2. Advocate for Stability: Leverage influence to advocate for policies and public discourse that reinforce democratic institutions and values, safeguarding the very foundations of economic prosperity. 3. Plan for the Long Term: Recognize that true, sustainable profits cannot exist without political and economic stability. 4. Seek Expert Guidance: Engage with data-driven experts who can provide precise insights into political risks and effective mitigation strategies.
The future of American capitalism and innovation depends on the urgent engagement of its business leaders. The time to act is now, before the window for a U-turn closes indefinitely.
Action Items
Business leaders must immediately acknowledge and seriously address the profound threat that political instability and democratic decline pose to long-term economic stability and shareholder value.
Impact: Early recognition of this systemic risk will enable proactive strategic planning and resource allocation to mitigate potential disruptions and protect corporate assets and market positions.
Overcome collective action problems by initiating coordination and collaboration among business leaders and industry groups to champion democratic principles.
Impact: Coordinated action amplifies impact, enabling the business community to exert significant influence on political outcomes and steer the nation towards greater stability, benefiting all stakeholders.
Engage in public advocacy campaigns that affirm the fundamental value of democracy for economic and social welfare, avoiding partisan endorsements (e.g., Brazil's business leaders).
Impact: Such campaigns can shift public discourse, encourage civic participation, and reinforce the institutional foundations essential for a predictable and prosperous business environment.
Integrate political instability risks into strategic business planning, understanding the detrimental economic and operational impacts of operating within an "incracy."
Impact: Proactive risk assessment allows businesses to develop resilient strategies, diversify investments, and prepare for potential market volatility, policy shifts, or supply chain disruptions.
Leverage data-driven insights and engage political scientists and experts to inform boards and management on the trajectory and implications of democratic decline.
Impact: Informed decision-making, based on expert analysis, enables businesses to craft more effective responses to political instability, identify critical intervention points, and allocate resources strategically.